Horse Academy

Eventing Safety Review: What Britain's New Commission Will Examine

British Eventing, the FEI and British Equestrian have asked an independent commission to look at rules, fences, training, medical cover and safety culture. Its public consultation is now open until December 23, 2026. Here's what it covers, how to have your say, and what riders can do now.

Updated 7 min read

A chestnut eventing horse and rider in a blue top and body protector clear a log fence lined with spruce trees on a parkland cross-country course.
Photo: US Eventing Association (opens in a new tab)

On November 12, 2026, the independent Eventing Horse and Rider Safety Commission, announced on October 26 and chaired by Dame Caroline Spelman, opened its public consultation and call for evidence. Anyone involved in eventing can respond until December 23, 2026.

TL;DR

  • Britain has set up an independent Eventing Horse and Rider Safety Commission, chaired by former Defra secretary of state Dame Caroline Spelman.
  • Its public consultation opened on November 12, 2026 and closes at 11:59pm on Wednesday, December 23, 2026. Anyone involved in eventing can respond, anonymously if they wish.
  • It will look at rules, course design, training, medical provision and safety culture, and aims to finish in about six months. Spelman says no outcome is decided in advance.
  • Cross-country is the riskiest phase because of fixed fences and speed. Frangible devices, body protectors, air vests and fall rules already exist to manage that risk.
  • A large British study of 749,534 cross-country starts found the odds of a horse fall rise with level and are higher for riders who had a horse fall at their previous start. Timing between runs mattered too, though not in a simple way.
Do you ride cross-country in a body protector, an air vest, or both?Answer

Were you there?

Send a photo or your result and we may add it to our next article, with credit.

For community members 13 and older. We review everything before it appears.

In this article(8)

What the new eventing safety commission is

Update (2026-11-12): The commission's public consultation and call for evidence is now open. It closes at 11:59pm on Wednesday, December 23, 2026; see "How to have your say" below.

On October 26, 2026, British Eventing (BE) announced an independent Eventing Horse and Rider Safety Commission to examine what more can be done to cut avoidable risk to horses and riders. It is chaired by Dame Caroline Spelman, a former Defra secretary of state, and set up with the British Eventing Support Trust, the FEI and British Equestrian.

BE's board pointed to two decades of accumulated safety knowledge, and to several recent serious incidents.

Here is the commission at a glance:

  • Who set it up: British Eventing, with the British Eventing Support Trust, the FEI (the sport's world governing body) and British Equestrian.
  • Who chairs it: Dame Caroline Spelman, a former Defra secretary of state.
  • What it covers: rules, course design, training, medical provision and safety culture.
  • Timeline: it aims to finish its work within about six months, so around spring 2027.
  • Openness: its findings and recommendations will be published.

Spelman said she would begin by listening to people in the sport and reviewing the evidence, and that listening stage has now started. She has also said no outcome is decided in advance, so any talk of specific new rules is guesswork for now.

How to have your say

The commission opened its public consultation and call for evidence on November 12, 2026. It asks how safe eventing is today and what more could reasonably be done to reduce avoidable risk to horses and riders.

  • Deadline: 11:59pm UK time on Wednesday, December 23, 2026.
  • Who can respond: anyone involved in eventing, from grassroots to international level. That includes riders, owners, grooms, coaches, volunteers, officials and organisers.
  • How long it takes: about 15 minutes for a short response (Chapters 1 and 12) and about an hour for a full one. You can answer as many or as few questions as you like.
  • How to respond: online, by email or by post. The survey link, the full consultation document and the addresses are on British Eventing's consultation page.
  • Privacy: you can respond anonymously. BE says responses go to the independent commission, are used only for its review and are not linked to membership records.

Two more routes are worth knowing:

  • A confidential route. Anyone who has been seriously injured, or who has lost a family member, can ask to speak to the commission privately through its secretariat.
  • Group sessions. The commission plans a small number of group discussions and evidence sessions in early December. To be considered, say so in Question 9 of the consultation.

A practical tip: BE recommends reading the questions alongside the full consultation document. Online answers save when you click Next, and you can return through the same link on the same device and browser.

Why cross-country is the riskiest phase

Eventing combines three tests: dressage, show jumping and cross-country. If you're new to the sport, our guide to what eventing is explains the format.

Cross-country is where most serious risk sits, for three main reasons:

  1. Solid fences. Show jumping fences are built to be knocked down. Many cross-country fences are built of fixed timber, banks, ditches and water.
  2. Speed and terrain. Horses gallop over open country, up and down hills, from one fence to the next.
  3. Rotational falls. This is when a horse hits a fence with its chest or front legs and somersaults over it. The USEA describes rotational falls as the type most often linked to rider deaths.

A 2023 study by researchers in the UK calls horse falls on cross-country the leading cause of rider deaths in eventing. That's why most safety work in the sport focuses on this phase.

What already exists to manage the risk

The commission isn't starting from zero. Here are the main tools already in use.

Frangible and deformable fences

A frangible fence is built to give way when a horse hits it hard enough, instead of acting as a fixed pivot. The best-known devices are MIM clips and frangible pins, which let a rail drop when hit with enough force.

  • Swedish-made MIM clips have been used at international horse trials for more than a decade, and in early 2021 they were the only devices to have passed the FEI's new testing standard.
  • Since January 1, 2021, approved devices are mandatory at international level on suitable open oxers, open corners, verticals with open rails, the top rail of triple bars and gates.
  • A newer yellow MIM clip releases with less force than the original red one and is meant for corners and table fences.

Body protectors and air vests

A body protector is compulsory for cross-country at British Eventing competitions. It must carry the BETA Level 3 (2018) label. BE's rules also accept an Exo Body Cage, which must be declared to the event secretary before cross-country. Older protectors certified only to the 2009 standard were ruled out from January 1, 2024, and BE's grace period for them ended on April 8, 2024. The Irish Pony Club's 2026 rules also require the BETA Level 3 (2018) standard or later. It is designed to spread out the force of hitting the ground or a fence.

An air vest inflates in a fraction of a second when a cord attached to the saddle pulls. Under the 2026 FEI rules, as summarized by the Irish Pony Club, air vests are recommended for cross-country but not compulsory, and must be worn over an approved body protector, never instead of one.

For how to choose and replace kit, see when to replace a riding helmet, and whether kids need a body protector or air vest.

Fall and qualification rules

  • One fall and you're out. Under a rule BE brought in for 2018, a rider fall during the dressage test, the show jumping round or on the cross-country course means elimination. A fall in the warm-up doesn't, but the rider can't carry on until an event doctor has cleared them. Riders who fall must be seen by the event doctor before they ride again or leave. Rules differ elsewhere: in US eventing, a rider fall in the dressage test costs marks but isn't an elimination.
  • Qualifications. From BE105 up, riders need a set number of qualifying results at lower levels, known as minimum eligibility requirements (MERs), and from Intermediate the horse needs them too. The entry levels work differently: BE80 and BE90 ask for none, and BE100 asks for them only from riders in the year of their 12th or 13th birthday.
  • Medical cover. Events have medical cover on site, and a veterinary officer must be present from 30 minutes before the first show jumping phase. For dressage held the day before, BE's steward may accept a vet who is immediately available on call instead. Under US rules, a medical armband or other medical data carrier is required only for riders with a relevant medical condition, so check what your own federation asks you to carry.

Head injuries need special care. Our explainer on concussion in horse riders covers why standard checks can miss them.

What the research says about cross-country falls

The largest study of eventing falls to date was published in the Equine Veterinary Journal (online in 2023, then in its January 2024 issue). A team of UK researchers, including authors at the University of Glasgow, analyzed 749,534 BE cross-country starts from 2005 to 2015.

They identified 16 risk factors for horse falls. Here's how the odds of a fall compared with the BE90 level:

LevelOdds of a fall vs BE90
BE100About 1.6 times
NoviceAbout 3.6 times
Intermediate8 times
AdvancedAbout 12.5 times

Other findings worth knowing:

  • Riders who had a horse fall at their previous start had about 2.4 times the odds of another at their next one. That is the rider's record, not necessarily the same horse's.
  • Horses on their first recorded start in the study had about twice the odds of a fall compared with horses that had run in the previous 1-14 days. The authors caution that this wasn't necessarily the horse's first start ever.
  • Every extra 10 dressage penalties went with slightly higher odds of a fall. A tense or green test can be an early warning.
  • Timing between runs mattered, but not in a straight line. Horses that had last run 15-21 days earlier had slightly lower odds of a fall than those back out within 1-14 days, and the rise after more than 28 days was not statistically significant. Horses with more starts in the previous 30 days had higher odds. The authors say this points to a carefully managed competition schedule and call for more research.

The authors suggest governing bodies use this kind of data to shape safety policy. They also note limits: the data covers only the UK and includes nothing on training at home.

What amateur and young riders can do now

You don't have to wait six months to ride more safely. These steps line up with the research and the existing rules:

  • Check your kit. Your body protector should carry a BETA Level 3 (2018) label and fit snugly. Replace your helmet after any hard fall.
  • Consider an air vest for cross-country, worn over your body protector. Follow the maker's checks for the lanyard and cartridge.
  • Move up slowly. The jump in risk from one level to the next is real. Get consistent clear rounds before stepping up.
  • Take a fall seriously. After any fall, get checked, rebuild with a confident schooling session and an easier run before trying anything bigger.
  • Plan the calendar. Space your runs instead of stacking them close together, and on a first run choose a friendly course and treat it as a confidence outing.
  • Read your dressage. If your horse was tense or distracted in the arena, ride the first cross-country fences more carefully.
  • Walk the course properly. Note which fences carry frangible devices and plan your line and pace at combinations.

Parents of young riders will find more in our safety section. For the bigger picture on levels, see CCI4*-S and eventing levels explained.

What to watch next

  • The consultation deadline. The call for evidence is open now and closes at 11:59pm on Wednesday, December 23, 2026.
  • Group evidence sessions. A small number are planned for early December; the announcement gives no exact dates.
  • The report, around spring 2027. The commission aims to finish within about six months of its October launch, and its findings will be made public.
  • How the FEI responds. The FEI is one of the bodies working with BE on the commission, so any recommendations could matter beyond Britain.
  • Your own federation. Many national federations follow FEI rule changes, so keep an eye on next year's rulebooks.

We'll update this story again when the consultation closes and when the commission publishes its findings. Follow more competition news on our trends page.

Coming up next

The next big events, with times in your zone and how to watch.

Do you ride cross-country in a body protector, an air vest, or both?

0 of 1,000 characters
Posting asks you to sign in. Your text stays here.

Quick reactions · One tap, no account needed

Learn the basics

Background from the Horse Academy library for this story.

What horse people are saying on X

Short paraphrased summaries of public posts. Open a post on X to read it in full.

  • @BEventing

    British Eventing says the independent safety commission's public consultation is open to everyone in the sport until December 23, 2026.

    View on X(@BEventing)
  • @horseandhound

    Horse & Hound flags the new independent review of eventing safety in Britain.

    View on X(@horseandhound)
  • @horseandhound

    Follow-up post linking to Horse & Hound's full story on the safety review.

    View on X(@horseandhound)

Frequently asked questions

What is the Eventing Horse and Rider Safety Commission?

It's an independent review set up on October 26, 2026 by British Eventing with the British Eventing Support Trust, the FEI and British Equestrian. It will examine rules, course design, training, medical provision and safety culture, and look at what more can be done to reduce avoidable risk.

Who is Caroline Spelman and why is she chairing it?

Dame Caroline Spelman is a former UK secretary of state at Defra, the government department for environment, food and rural affairs. She said she would start by listening and reviewing the evidence, with no outcome decided in advance; the public consultation opened on November 12, 2026.

How can I respond to the eventing safety consultation?

You can respond online, by email or by post until 11:59pm UK time on Wednesday, December 23, 2026. The survey link, the full consultation document and the addresses are on British Eventing's consultation page. A short response takes about 15 minutes and a full one about an hour.

Who can take part, and can I respond anonymously?

Anyone involved in eventing can respond, from grassroots to international level: riders, owners, grooms, coaches, volunteers, officials and organisers. Responses can be anonymous and British Eventing says they are not linked to membership records. People who have been seriously injured or bereaved can ask to speak to the commission in confidence.

When will the commission report?

It aims to complete its work within about six months, which points to around spring 2027. Its findings and recommendations will be published.

Why is cross-country the most dangerous part of eventing?

Many cross-country fences are solid and the horses jump them at speed over varied terrain. The most serious danger is a rotational fall, when a horse hits a fence with its chest or front legs and somersaults. Horse falls on cross-country are the leading cause of rider deaths in the sport.

What is a frangible fence in eventing?

It's a cross-country fence fitted with a device, such as a MIM clip or frangible pin, that lets the rail drop when a horse hits it hard enough. The aim is to prevent rotational falls. Approved devices have been mandatory on suitable fences at international level since January 1, 2021.

Is an air vest compulsory for eventing?

Not under the 2026 FEI rules: air vests are recommended for cross-country, not required. A body protector with the BETA Level 3 (2018) label is compulsory for cross-country at British Eventing and Irish Pony Club competitions (BE also accepts a declared Exo Body Cage), and an air vest must be worn over it, never instead of it. Always check your own federation's current rulebook.

Sources

  1. MIMclip Leads the Way in Frangible Technology

    US Eventing Association · Jan 19, 2021

  2. IPC Cross Country Tack Sheet 2026

    Irish Pony Club · Jan 1, 2026

  3. Eventers get more time to upgrade body protectors

    Equestrian Trade News · Mar 6, 2024

  4. Rule Changes 2026

    British Eventing · Jan 30, 2026

  5. 2026 Overview of Eventing Rules

    US Eventing Association · Jan 27, 2026

Was this story useful?

Share this article