Horse Academy

Makybe Diva Trophies Stolen: What We Know About the Flemington Theft

The three gold cups won by the only three-time Melbourne Cup winner were taken from a display cabinet at Flemington on Monday morning. Police are investigating, and her owner wants them back in one piece.

Updated 5 min read

Smashed glass display case at Flemington holding a bronze horse statue, horseshoes and red and white checked racing silks beside a mural of a jockey on a bay horse
Photo: ABC News (Australia) (opens in a new tab)

The three Melbourne Cups won by Australia's most famous mare were stolen from Flemington on Nov 16, 2026, less than nine months after she died. Racing fans want to know what happened and whether the cups can be recovered.

TL;DR

  • Makybe Diva's three Melbourne Cup trophies (2003, 2004, 2005) were stolen from a display cabinet at Flemington Racecourse on Monday, Nov 16, 2026.
  • Victoria Police say the cups were taken from a cabinet on Epsom Road at about 6:30am. They are treating it as a burglary and theft, and the investigation is ongoing.
  • Owner-breeder Tony Santic called the cups irreplaceable and asked for them to be returned in one piece. The Victoria Racing Club (VRC) said it is devastated.
  • Reports that the thieves dressed as workers in hi-vis come from Santic and racecourse workers, not from police.
  • Anyone with information, dashcam or CCTV footage is asked to contact Crime Stoppers Victoria.
Which racing trophy or keepsake would you most hate to see lost, and why?Answer
In this article(7)

Makybe Diva trophies stolen: what happened at Flemington

The three gold Melbourne Cup trophies that Makybe Diva won in 2003, 2004 and 2005 were stolen from a display cabinet at Flemington Racecourse in Melbourne on the morning of Monday, Nov 16, 2026. Victoria Police are treating it as a burglary and theft, and the cups have not been reported found.

The cups were at the track for an exhibition called Makybe Diva: Queen of the Cups. The Victoria Racing Club (VRC), which runs Flemington, opened it for Makybe Diva Stakes Day on Sept 12 and brought all three trophies together in the Hill Stand.

They belong to Tony Santic, the mare's owner and breeder. It is a painful year for him: Makybe Diva died on Feb 28, 2026, after a sudden bout of colic.

What police and the VRC have confirmed

Here is what comes from official statements, as reported by ABC News and the Racing Post:

  • When: about 6:30am on Monday, Nov 16 (Melbourne time). Some early reports gave a later time; we are using the police one.
  • Where: a cabinet on Epsom Road at Flemington, near the entrance to the Hill Stand.
  • What: police said “it is believed three Melbourne Cup trophies were stolen from a cabinet.”
  • Status: police said the circumstances are yet to be established and the investigation is ongoing.
  • The club: the VRC said it reported the theft immediately, is helping police and is “devastated by the incident.”

No arrests have been announced, and police have not described any suspects.

What is reported but not confirmed

Santic told ABC News he was told that two thieves broke in dressed as workers in high-visibility clothing. Two workers at the racecourse told the ABC it looked as if someone had used a glass cutter or similar tool, and that people in hi-vis with a ladder would have blended in.

Racing media have repeated the “fake construction workers” account. Police have not confirmed it, so treat it as a claim for now.

We are also not putting a dollar value on the cups. Figures are circulating online, but none comes from police or the VRC.

What Tony Santic said

Santic told the ABC he was “totally devastated.” He said he wants the trophies back in one piece and would forgive whoever took them if they return the cups and tell police where they are.

On Melbourne radio station 3AW's Drive program, as reported by the Racing Post, he said: “They are irreplaceable and it breaks my heart that someone's gone out and pinched them.” The Racing Post also reported that he fears the gold could be melted down.

That is the real worry. As metal, a cup can be replaced. As the 2003, 2004 and 2005 Melbourne Cups, these three cannot.

Why Makybe Diva is the only horse with three Melbourne Cups

The Melbourne Cup is a 3,200-metre handicap run at Flemington on the first Tuesday in November. In a handicap, the handicapper sets weights to even out the field, and a win usually brings a higher rating, so a past winner often has to carry more weight to win again.

Since the first Cup in 1861, only four other horses have won it even twice: Archer, Peter Pan, Rain Lover and Think Big. Makybe Diva won three in a row, carrying more weight each time.

YearWeightTrainerJockey
200351 kgDavid HallGlen Boss
200455.5 kgLee FreedmanGlen Boss
200558 kgLee FreedmanGlen Boss

A few more facts worth knowing:

  • She was foaled in England in March 1999 and raced for Santic. Almost all her racing was in Australia; her only starts abroad were two runs in Japan in 2005, where she finished seventh in the April Stakes and the Tenno Sho (Spring).
  • Her name is built from the first two letters of the names of five of Santic's employees.
  • She also won the 2005 Cox Plate, the 2004 Sydney Cup and the 2005 Australian Cup.
  • She retired straight after the third Cup with 15 wins from 36 starts and more than A$14.5 million in prize money.
  • A bronze statue of her stands at Flemington, and she is in the Australian Racing Hall of Fame.

Her death in February came from colic, a broad term for abdominal pain that can turn serious fast. Our guide to early colic signs explains what owners watch for. If you think your horse has colic, call your vet straight away.

What a Melbourne Cup trophy is, and why the owner keeps it

Many famous trophies are perpetual: one cup, passed from winner to winner. The Melbourne Cup works the other way.

  • A new cup every year. Each one becomes the property of the winning owner, which is why Santic had three.
  • The shape. It is a three-handled “loving cup”, a design first awarded in 1919. The handles are often said to stand for owner, trainer and jockey.
  • The metal. The cup is handmade in 18-carat gold. The current makers say each one takes more than 250 hours.
  • Who else gets a prize. The trainer and jockey receive miniature replicas, and the strapper (the groom who looks after the horse) gets the Tommy Woodcock Trophy.

So these three cups are not copies of something held elsewhere. Each is the cup Santic was presented as the winning owner that year (a spare is kept on hand only in case of a dead heat), and together they are the physical record of a feat no other horse has matched.

That is why the theft has hit Australian racing so hard. This year's race is already run, with Point Of Law winning the 2026 Melbourne Cup, but for many fans Makybe Diva is still the horse the Cup is measured against. New to racing terms like handicap and strapper? Our glossary helps.

What to do if you know something, and what to watch next

Police and the VRC are asking for help from the public. If you were near Flemington early on Monday:

  1. Check dashcam or CCTV footage from around Epsom Road at about 6:30am.
  2. Contact Crime Stoppers Victoria at crimestoppersvic.com.au, the channel police and the VRC named.
  3. If you are offered a Melbourne Cup trophy or unusual gold items, do not buy them. Report it.
  4. Do not share names or guesses about suspects online. It can harm innocent people and the case.

What we will be watching for:

  • A police update on how the cabinet was breached and whether the hi-vis account holds up.
  • Any release of CCTV images or a description of the people involved.
  • What the VRC says about security for trophies and memorabilia on display.
  • Whether the cups are recovered intact.

We will update this article when police or the VRC confirm something new. For more racing stories, see Trends.

Coming up next

The next big events, with times in your zone and how to watch.

Which racing trophy or keepsake would you most hate to see lost, and why?

0 of 1,000 characters
Posting asks you to sign in. Your text stays here.

Quick reactions · One tap, no account needed

Learn the basics

Background from the Horse Academy library for this story.

What horse people are saying on X

Short paraphrased summaries of public posts. Open a post on X to read it in full.

  • @Racing

    Racing.com reports that Makybe Diva's three Melbourne Cups were taken from Flemington that morning.

    View on X(@Racing)
  • @9NewsMelb

    9News Melbourne reports the cups were taken from a display cabinet in the Hill Stand, with the thieves reportedly disguised as tradespeople.

    View on X(@9NewsMelb)
  • @abcnews

    ABC News shares its report on the theft of the three Melbourne Cups won by Makybe Diva.

    View on X(@abcnews)
  • @SEN_track

    SEN Track relays the account that people posing as construction workers broke the glass case and left with the three cups.

    View on X(@SEN_track)

Frequently asked questions

Were Makybe Diva's Melbourne Cup trophies really stolen?

Yes. Victoria Police say three Melbourne Cup trophies were taken from a cabinet on Epsom Road at Flemington at about 6:30am on Monday, Nov 16, 2026. They are the cups Makybe Diva won in 2003, 2004 and 2005, and police are investigating a burglary and theft.

Have the stolen Melbourne Cups been found?

Not as of Nov 16, 2026. Police said the circumstances are yet to be established and the investigation is ongoing. No arrests or recoveries have been announced.

Who stole Makybe Diva's trophies?

Nobody has been identified. Owner Tony Santic said he was told two thieves were dressed as workers in hi-vis clothing, and racecourse workers gave a similar picture to ABC News, but police have not confirmed that account or described any suspects.

Why did Makybe Diva's owner have three separate Melbourne Cups?

A new Melbourne Cup trophy is made every year and becomes the property of the winning owner. Makybe Diva won in 2003, 2004 and 2005, so Tony Santic received three cups, one for each year.

Is Makybe Diva still alive?

No. Makybe Diva died on Feb 28, 2026, after a sudden bout of colic. She was foaled in March 1999; reports give her age as 26 or 27, depending on how it is counted.

How can I report information about the Flemington theft?

Police and the VRC ask anyone who saw the theft or has dashcam or CCTV footage to contact Crime Stoppers Victoria at crimestoppersvic.com.au.

Sources

  1. Vale Makybe Diva

    Victoria Racing Club · Feb 28, 2026

  2. Japan Racing Journal, July 2005: Review of JRA Races in 1st Half of 2005

    Japan Association for International Horse Racing · Jul 1, 2005

  3. Handicapping

    Racing Victoria · Nov 16, 2026

  4. Makybe Diva

    Wikipedia · Nov 16, 2026

  5. Melbourne Cup

    Wikipedia · Nov 16, 2026

Was this story useful?

Share this article