Horse Academy

Horse Soring: USDA's New Horse Protection Act Proposal Explained

On November 13, 2026, USDA proposed rewriting how the federal ban on soring is enforced at horse shows. The agency calls it stronger enforcement; Humane World for Animals calls it a rollback. Here is what the proposal says, and how to comment by December 14.

Updated 6 min read

Close-up of a gray horse's front legs on arena dirt, wearing shiny black stacked hoof pads and metal action chains around both pasterns.

USDA published a proposed Horse Protection Act rule on November 13, 2026, and the public comment window closes December 14. Welfare groups and the walking horse industry are describing the same document in opposite terms.

TL;DR

  • Soring means deliberately causing pain in a horse's legs or hooves to exaggerate its gait. Federal law has banned showing or selling sored horses since 1970.
  • On November 13, 2026, USDA's APHIS proposed withdrawing what is left of its 2024 rule and replacing it. The docket is APHIS-2026-0067.
  • The proposal keeps industry-licensed inspectors with tighter standards, adds swab and blood testing, removes the scar rule and disqualifies a sore horse from one class instead of the whole show. APHIS had already stopped enforcing the scar rule and the "no show back" policy for 2026.
  • APHIS describes it as stronger, fairer enforcement. Humane World for Animals says it returns inspections to the industry and weakens protection.
  • Anyone can comment at regulations.gov until December 14, 2026. Nothing changes until a final rule is issued.
Who would you trust to inspect horses at a show: industry or independent inspectors?Answer
In this article(8)

What is horse soring, and what did USDA just propose?

Horse soring is deliberately causing pain in a horse's lower legs or hooves so that it snatches its front feet higher and faster in the show ring. On November 13, 2026, the USDA's Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) published a proposed rule that would rewrite how the federal ban on soring is enforced, and the public can comment until December 14, 2026.

The practice is tied mainly to the "Big Lick," the exaggerated high-stepping gait shown by some Tennessee Walking Horses and racking horses. APHIS itself describes soring as cruel and inhumane, and as a way to gain an unfair advantage over horses trained honestly.

We are not going to describe how it is done. What matters for most readers is what the law says, how inspections work and what this proposal would change.

The Horse Protection Act, from 1970 to now

Congress passed the Horse Protection Act (HPA) in 1970. It bans showing, exhibiting or selling a sore horse at shows, exhibitions, sales and auctions, and transporting one when there is reason to believe it will be shown or sold while sore (ordinary commercial carriers are exempt unless they have reason to believe the horse is sore). It also holds owners responsible if they allow it.

Enforcement has always been the hard part. The recent timeline looks like this:

  • May 2024: APHIS finalizes a new rule. It would replace the industry-run inspection program with inspectors trained and licensed by APHIS, ban action devices and non-therapeutic pads on Tennessee Walking Horses and racking horses, and replace the "scar rule."
  • January 2025: The U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas vacates the ban on pads and action devices and the scar-rule replacement. According to the trade publication Walking Horse Report, the court left standing USDA's authority to replace the industry inspection system.
  • 2025: A separate lawsuit challenges the older rules still on the books, and an August preliminary injunction blocks parts of them. In November, a House committee report directs APHIS to withdraw the 2024 rule.
  • January 28, 2026: APHIS postpones the surviving parts of the 2024 rule again, this time to December 31, 2026. The one exception is the section on authorizing and training APHIS inspectors (§11.19), which has been in effect since June 7, 2024.
  • 2026 show season: APHIS tells shows it will not enforce the scar rule or the "no show back" policy this year.
  • November 13, 2026: APHIS proposes to withdraw those surviving parts and write a new framework instead.

That last step is the news. If the proposal is finalized, the independent-inspector system from 2024 never takes effect.

What the 2026 proposed rule would change

The Horse Protection Act proposed rule 2026 sits in docket APHIS-2026-0067. Based on APHIS's own summary and coverage by Legis1 and Walking Horse Report, these are the main points.

Issue2024 rule2026 proposal
Who inspectsInspectors trained and licensed by APHISIndustry-licensed inspectors stay, with stricter standards
Scar ruleReplaced (vacated by the court)Removed
Pads, action devicesBanned (vacated by the court)No broad ban; on walking and racking horses, pads come off for first-place horses (once a day for repeat winners) and on suspicion

Who inspects

Today, show management can hire a Designated Qualified Person (DQP), an inspector licensed through a horse industry organization (HIO) that USDA certifies. The proposal keeps that system.

APHIS says it would tighten conflict-of-interest rules and competency standards, provide training from experienced equine veterinarians, add an apprenticeship and evaluate inspectors before and after licensing.

How horses are checked

APHIS says inspections would add swabbing, blood testing and expanded movement exams. Substances that mask soring, such as sedatives and topical numbing agents, would be prohibited, and interfering with an inspection would be barred more clearly.

What happens when a horse is found sore

When APHIS inspects, two APHIS veterinarians would have to inspect the horse independently and agree on a finding before the person responsible for the horse is notified, and the exhibitor could appeal on the spot to a neutral Appeals Official. Findings by a DQP would follow a different track: each HIO would have to set its own procedure for contesting them, which could include a second DQP inspecting the horse on request.

A horse found sore would be disqualified from the class it was inspected for, not from the rest of the event. Walking Horse Report says the horse could be presented again and, if it passes, compete in a later class. That is already how the 2026 season works: APHIS told shows it would not enforce the "no show back" policy this year, and that management may let a disqualified horse be reinspected for another class. The proposal would write that into the rules.

The scar rule

The scar rule treats certain scarring on the lower legs as evidence of soring. APHIS already said it would not enforce the rule, or require shows to enforce it, during the 2026 season. The proposal would remove it formally, with APHIS saying a district court found it likely exceeds USDA's authority; the law's own definition of a sore horse would still apply.

Strengthening or rollback? The two readings

The same document is being described in opposite ways, so check who is speaking.

APHIS titles its announcement a proposal to strengthen enforcement of the Act. It says the changes modernize inspections, make them consistent between events and give exhibitors due process. Farm trade outlet Feedstuffs ran the news under a similar "strengthening" headline.

Walking Horse Report, which covers the industry, called the proposal a significant victory for the Tennessee Walking Horse industry.

Humane World for Animals and Humane World Action Fund, formerly the Humane Society of the United States and its legislative fund, called it a sweeping rollback. They say it abandons the independent inspector program from 2024, returns inspections to industry organizations, drops the scar rule with no replacement and lets a horse found sore come back for later classes.

The groups also point to a 2010 USDA Inspector General audit that recommended ending industry self-policing. They sued USDA earlier in 2026 over the delays to the 2024 rule, and they say this proposal is not the result of a ruling in that case.

Both sides agree on what the text does. They disagree on whether it will catch more sored horses or fewer. The best way to judge is to read the Federal Register notice itself (document 2026-23086), linked from APHIS's proposed rule page.

How inspections at shows work, and signs you might notice

Under the current rules, a DQP watches the horse move, feels along the pasterns with their hands and checks the equipment. USDA inspectors also attend some events, where they can inspect horses, watch the warm-up ring and observe the DQPs.

If management hires no DQP, it is liable for any sore horse that competes. Penalties under the Act include civil fines of up to $7,183 per violation (the law's $2,000 cap, adjusted for inflation) and disqualification of at least one year for a first violation and at least five for later ones.

As a spectator or owner, you cannot diagnose soring from the rail. Educational material from the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) describes general pain signs worth knowing:

  • A horse that is unwilling to move, or moves with short, choppy steps.
  • A horse that spends unusually long periods lying down in the stall.
  • An odd posture, with the hind legs tucked far under the body to take weight off the front feet.
  • A strong reaction when the lower front legs are touched.

These signs can come from many painful conditions, so they call for a veterinarian, not a conclusion. Our health basics guide covers what normal looks like.

To report a suspected Horse Protection Act violation, APHIS takes complaints through its online animal welfare complaint form, by email at horseprotection@usda.gov or by phone at 970-494-7478.

It also helps to keep the breed separate from the practice. Tennessee Walking Horses are naturally smooth-gaited, and many are shown flat-shod or ridden on trails with no connection to the Big Lick. See our breeds section for more on gaited horses.

How to comment on the Horse Protection Act proposal

Anyone can comment, not only people in the walking horse world. Here is how to comment on the Horse Protection Act proposal:

  1. Read the proposal first, or at least APHIS's summary.
  2. Go to regulations.gov and search for docket APHIS-2026-0067.
  3. Open the Documents tab and click Comment next to the proposed rule.
  4. Write your comment and submit it by December 14, 2026.

You can also mail it to Docket No. APHIS-2026-0067, Regulatory Analysis and Development, PPD, APHIS, 5601 Sunnyside Ave, Beltsville, MD 20740.

A few practical points:

  • Comments become part of the public record, so leave out anything private.
  • Specific comments carry more weight than general ones. Point to the provision you mean and explain your experience or evidence.
  • What you say is up to you. Trainers, veterinarians, show managers, owners and spectators all see this from different places.

What to watch next

  • December 14, 2026: the comment period closes.
  • December 31, 2026: the date the postponed parts of the 2024 rule are currently set to take effect (the inspector-training section is already in force). APHIS proposes to withdraw them, so watch for another notice before then.
  • After that: APHIS has given no timeline for a final rule. Until one is issued, the proposal changes nothing at shows.
  • In court and Congress: watch the lawsuit Humane World filed earlier in 2026, and the PAST Act, a bill the welfare groups back that would change the law itself.

For how another part of the horse world handles welfare cases, see our explainer on the FEI's horse abuse rules. If you show gaited horses or have been through an inspection, tell us how it went in the community.

Coming up next

The next big events, with times in your zone and how to watch.

Who would you trust to inspect horses at a show: industry or independent inspectors?

0 of 1,000 characters
Posting asks you to sign in. Your text stays here.

Quick reactions · One tap, no account needed

Learn the basics

Background from the Horse Academy library for this story.

What horse people are saying on X

Short paraphrased summaries of public posts. Open a post on X to read it in full.

  • @USDA_APHIS

    APHIS asks for public comment by December 14 on a proposed Horse Protection Act rule it says promotes fair competition and helps end soring.

    View on X(@USDA_APHIS)
  • @humaneactfund

    Humane World Action Fund says the USDA proposal would set back efforts to end soring and the exaggerated Big Lick gait.

    View on X(@humaneactfund)
  • @hoofcare

    American Farriers Journal reports that APHIS opened a comment period from November 13 to December 14 on its proposed Horse Protection Act changes.

    View on X(@hoofcare)
  • @HighCountryObsv

    A local news outlet summarizes the proposal: withdraw the rest of the 2024 rule, keep industry inspectors under tighter oversight, expand testing and remove the scar rule.

    View on X(@HighCountryObsv)

Frequently asked questions

What is horse soring?

Soring is deliberately causing pain in a horse's lower legs or hooves so it lifts its front feet higher and faster, exaggerating its gait in the show ring. It is associated mainly with the "Big Lick" gait in some Tennessee Walking Horses and racking horses. Since 1970, the federal Horse Protection Act has banned showing or selling sored horses, and transporting them when there is reason to believe they will be shown or sold while sore.

What does the 2026 Horse Protection Act proposed rule change?

APHIS proposes withdrawing the remaining parts of its 2024 rule. In their place it would keep industry-licensed inspectors (DQPs) with stricter training and conflict-of-interest standards, add swab and blood testing, ban masking substances, remove the scar rule, require two APHIS veterinarians to agree on an APHIS finding, allow on-site appeals of APHIS findings (DQP findings would be contested under each HIO's procedures), and disqualify a sore horse from the inspected class instead of the whole event.

Is the Big Lick being banned?

Not under this proposal. The 2024 rule would have banned action devices and non-therapeutic pads on Tennessee Walking Horses and racking horses, but a federal court vacated that part in January 2025. The 2026 proposal does not bring back a broad ban. For those breeds, APHIS says pads would be removed for inspection on first-place horses (no more than once a day for a horse that wins several classes that day) and whenever an inspector considers it necessary.

How do I comment on the Horse Protection Act proposal?

Go to regulations.gov, search for docket APHIS-2026-0067, open the Documents tab and click Comment next to the proposed rule. You can also mail a comment to APHIS's Regulatory Analysis and Development office in Beltsville, Maryland. The deadline is December 14, 2026, and comments become public.

When would the new soring rules take effect?

There is no date yet. This is a proposal, and APHIS has not given a timeline for a final rule after comments close on December 14, 2026. Separately, the postponed parts of the 2024 rule are currently scheduled to take effect on December 31, 2026, and APHIS proposes to withdraw them. One section, on authorizing and training APHIS inspectors (§11.19), has been in effect since June 7, 2024.

How do I report suspected soring?

APHIS accepts Horse Protection Act complaints through its online animal welfare complaint form, by email at horseprotection@usda.gov or by phone at 970-494-7478. Describe what you saw, where and when. Do not handle or examine someone else's horse yourself.

Sources

  1. 2026 Horse Protection Proposed Rule

    USDA APHIS · Nov 12, 2026

  2. Horse Protection Act

    USDA APHIS · Nov 17, 2026

  3. 15 U.S. Code § 1824: Unlawful acts

    Legal Information Institute

Was this story useful?

Share this article

  • Horse NewsHot

    Central Park Carriage Horses: What Happens Now Under Romanch's Law

    9 min read

  • Horse NewsHot

    Makybe Diva Trophies Stolen: Man Arrested, Cups Still Missing

    8 min read